COVID-19 is a worldwide pandemic. And with the populations of entire countries confined to their homes... our internet habits are changing drastically.
Globally, we’re spending more and more time online. Industry giants like Facebook, Youtube, Disney, and Amazon are seeing massive lifts in traffic and are straining to keep their systems running optimally. And our bandwidth requirements keep reaching unprecedented highs.
Cloudflare, a company dedicated to “making the internet work the way it should,” has tracked incredible shifts in internet traffic that correlate directly with quarantine and government announcements.
It looks like humanity is sitting their computers, anxiously consuming content at a record rate.
So what’s going on in email? How are people changing their inbox habits?
To help you understand what’s happening, I’m publishing Paved’s internal stats (and some early insights) to add to the ongoing conversation around email marketing, internet usage, and eCommerce during the crisis.
This article was originally released on March 27, 2020
Where data is coming from: The data Paved has access to is provided by 600+ email newsletters. These newsletters represent over 150 million individual subscribers around the world.
How we’ve made sense of the shifts: We're looking specifically at how user behavior has changed From January 27- February 23 and February 23 to March 22.
Useful Resources: Find links to other industry-relevant posts covering the COVID-19 pandemic at the bottom of this post.
How COVID-19 is Affecting Email Engagement
08/06/2020 UPDATE:
We’re officially halfway through 2020 and it feels like decades have passed. Lockdown is still in effect (although greatly reduced across the world), millions have lost their jobs, and governments struggle to walk the fine line between a health crisis and economic devastation.
So… what’s happening in people’s inboxes? We took a look at the year on year data to find out.
From January to May 2019, email open rates hovered between 23% and 24%. In 2020, the rates for January and February were almost exactly the same as the year before.
As the pandemic hit the US in March, engagement spiked. There was a 10% year on year increase in newsletter opens in March. April a lower 6%, and May went back up to 8%.
While the open rate is interesting, the difference in click-through rates (CTR) tells a fascinating story.
As early as February, people started frantically clicking on newsletter links. CTRs jumped a massive 22% (from 4.10% to 5%). March took us up even higher to 24%, and April saw a 20% increase compared to April 2019.
May saw a significant drop in CTR, going down from 20% to just a 7% increase. On a general interest note, unsubscribes were sitting at 0% change (despite unsubscribe levels being marginally higher in previous months).
In theory, this could mean that people are starting to spend less time engaging with their inboxes -- not unsurprising considering the relaxing of lockdowns worldwide.
Follow us on Twitter to be notified when the next update is released.
06/04/2020 UPDATE:
Most major countries are on lockdown. Governments have effectively restricted the movement of a third of our planet’s population. Seeing as COVID-19 is now affecting most of the world, we’ve switched from specific locations to global stats.
Open rates increase: Comparing the last 3 weeks of January (pre-COVID-19 measures in the west) with the last 3 weeks of March, global open rates have increased by 21%. People are opening their emails a LOT more.
But publishers aren’t sending more: The send volume last week was comparable to the volume we usually see late December. Publishers aren’t moving fast enough to take advantage of this increase in engagement. Key takeaway: Don’t assume subscribers are overloaded — the desire for valuable content is higher than ever before.
Click rates aren’t keeping up: While open rates are up 21%, click-through rates only increased by 3.9%. If you’re a publisher, now is the time to experiment with call to actions and push that extra engagement as far as possible.
Open rates in Italy went up 57% in the last 4 weeks.
Italy started regional lockdown on February 27, which then progressed to a full nationwide lockdown on March 9. The first lockdown came with a dramatic lift in open rates. A trend that continues as the nation remains indoors.
Open rates in Italy increased from 19.20% to 30.20% in a 4-week comparison period.
New York State’s open rates increased by 14% in a 4 week period. Since New York City started their lockdown, open rates jumped by 15.75%.
New Yorkers are famous for not “doing what they're told”. But as I’m witnessing first-hand, the speed and severity of COVID-19 is making people take it seriously and stay home. And that unsurprisingly correlates with an increase in open rates.
The whole New York state saw a lift of 14% while the city jumped an extra 15.75% in the week the lockdown came into effect.
Global open rates are up by 15% in the last 4 weeks.
From January to about mid-February, global open rates held steady between 19% and 20%. As the COVID-19 situation began to get more serious on a global scale, open rates climbed.
In March, global open rates jumped from 19.3% to 22.1%. As of March 22, they went up to 23.0%. An effective increase of 15%.
Startup founder and marketer Rand Fishkin thinks online activity will stay up as people try to stave off anxiety about an uncertain future with an endless stream of content. For the email industry, that means more emails, opened more often.
People are opening their emails faster across the globe. The open rate for the first hour after a newsletter is sent is up 28.6%.
Along with general open rates going up, the time it takes for people to actually open an email is decreasing. In the first week of March, time to open began to rise.
The graph above shows the percentage of emails opened in the first hour of delivery. It currently sits at 11.12% of emails - an effective increase of 28.6% from January to February.
The rise in email open rates is paralleled by a drop in ad costs. And engagement is your secret weapon.
Online activity has increased across the board. But not every business sector is equipped to turn this activity into cold hard cash. As people’s priorities change, some eCommerce sectors are booming while others are slowing down.
Apparel has been particularly hard hit. And the emerging shifts are complex and difficult to predict. Walmart recently reported that they’re selling more shirts than bottoms. A phenomenon they’ve attributed to online meetings (people are wearing a pressed shirt on their top half with old gym pants below).
Aaron Orendorff from The Common Thread Collective (an eCommerce growth agency) has reported a ~30% decrease in CPM and 13% in CPC for their clients. The cost of advertising is going down. Which is great for advertisers, but it’s not without complications.
“People are happy to have something to occupy them — like open an email or click an ad — but reluctant to take action after that. Simply put, more people are online more often with less to keep them busy.”
So what does this lack of action mean? And how do we get a consumer who’s clicked an ad to act?
As Aaron went on to say, “Conversion rate optimization and honing the offer within the first click (whether that’s email or any other form of marketing media) are at an all-time premium right now.”
Point is, if you’re a B2B company or an e-commerce company with a longer sales cycle… this is a good time to scale up your advertising efforts. If you want someone to take 30 minutes out of their busy day to read your white paper or sign up for a webinar series, now is the time. It’s all about engagement, not hard sales.
Insights for eCommerce and Digital Marketing
Online Spending in the US could go either way
According to SimilarWeb’s whitepaper, global eCommerce is on a downward trend… except for the US. This is attributed to mass-market brands and an established household goods supply chain. According to this article, week on week sales are up on baby products, toys/ games, and sports/fitness (8.67%, 88.42%, 76.87% respectively).
Despite uncertainty about the future, most governments are sending checks or monetary relief to ease the economic burden on individuals and businesses. While vital to people who’ve lost their employment, those working remotely will have an extra injection of cash to spend.
And with quarantines in effect, most of that money will be spent online.
While online activity is higher than ever before, businesses avoid spending on digital advertising
It’s not surprising. In a recession, the growth-centric thinking of “get more revenue” shifts to the risk-averse “save more money” mindset.
Media-based businesses (like The Hustle) are claiming that advertisers are slowing spend as much as possible and trying to pause or pull out of agreements. And even as Facebook ramps up services to keep the platform running, it’s reporting a drop in ad revenue.
COVID-19 anxiety will likely continue for 30 to 60 days before the dust settles, online life becomes the norm, and digital marketing increases in importance.
Digital Advertising Space vs the Coronavirus
Media buyers, the people who buy digital ad space on the internet, have been blacklisting content that covers the coronavirus.
The implication for news outlets and creators has been massive. The New York Times even forecasted a drop in ad revenue by 10% due to COVID-19 being blacklisted as negative content by advertisers. This only applies to on-site activity, not email advertising or newsletter sponsorships.
The future is uncertain, but that’s no surprise.
No one can predict what will happen in the future. That statement was accurate before COVID-19. But with the shape of the future changing so rapidly, it’s more important than ever to avoid knee-jerk reactions and look to data for the answers.
Tweet at us if you have questions. @pavedemail
Resources:
Top 100 Fastest Growing & Declining Categories in E-commerce: A useful infographic list of 100 categories in e-commmerce and how they have been affected by coronavirus.
Coronavirus' Ecommerce Impact: Data, Guidance & How to Respond: Updated daily with the latest e-commerce shifts illustrated through $50M+ of annual ad spend.
Coronavirus Government Relief Programs for Small Business: Quick-relief program links from around the world. 17 countries and counting.
What The Coronavirus (COVID-19) Means For Marketers: SEO data on traffic volumes and conversion stats for various industries.
Prevention of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19): Practical advice from the CDC.
Who's staying home because of COVID-19?: List of companies, events, and universities in tech who’re working from home.
Coronavirus: The Hammer and the Dance: Comprehensive resource (based on data) on how governments responded and are responding. Plus insight into a landscape of the future.
Understanding the Global Impact of the Coronavirus on Sectors and Industries: A comprehensive report from March 16 on online trends based on web traffic.




